The Best USMNT XI (August 2014)

 

Geoff Cameron (Photo: ISIphotos.com)
Geoff Cameron (Photo: ISIphotos.com)

 

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

 

With the September friendlies coming up, here is World Soccer Source’s Best USA XI for August 2014:

 

 

GOALKEEPER: Brad GUZAN

 

Now seems like the time for Tim Howard to pass the torch to Brad Guzan. Guzan is arguably as good as Howard, and certain aspects of his game are better than Howard’s, such as his knowledge of when to come off his line and when to stay on it. Guzan’s club performances in the EPL and his performances for the United States prove his ability to be the USMNT Number 1 right now. Guzan has been as good and as consistent as Howard for years.

 

 

RIGHT BACK: DeAndre YEDLIN

 

DeAndre Yedlin is the undisputed starting right back for the United States. Yedlin can track down and tackle basically any attacker regardless of their speed, and Yedlin is excellent in his ability to get down the sideline in the attack, play crosses, and play quality passes to midfielders and attacker in and around the penalty box. Yedlin was tossed into the deep end at the World Cup and he not only held his own but his skill and excellence stood out. The interest from European clubs in Yedlin solidifies his spot as the starting USA right back.

 

 

CENTER BACK: Geoff CAMERON

 

Geoff Cameron is the best American center back in the pool, and his combination of defending, size, skill, and athleticism makes his inclusion as a starter over Omar Gonzalez undeniable. All defenders make mistakes and get beaten, but Cameron offers the United States the most capable and competitive center back to play the right center back spot. Cameron has a great weaker left foot, and he’s equally as skilled as a left center back.

 

 

CENTER BACK: John BROOKS

 

Matt Besler is the lock starter at the left center back spot for most observers, but Brooks is better than Besler almost in every defensive, technical, and athletic category – and Brooks is a better combination of all of these categories. Brooks is a better 1v1 defender with more technical ability than Besler. Brooks is also better in the air defensively and on set pieces in the attack. Brooks proved his worth at the 2014 World Cup, and despite Besler’s quality play at the World Cup, now is the time to give Brooks the job.

 

 

LEFT BACK: Chris KLUTE

 

Chris Klute needs to be more aggressive in his willingness to look to score and cut inside toward the penalty box, but Klute’s two-footed skill and ability to get forward with the attack and back on defense with world-class speed make him an outside back that the United States needs to use as a starter now. Klute needs to be allowed to make mistakes and get more experience as well. Klute is an investment that needs to be made now so that he can reach his full potential and become more complete soon. Making Klute wait longer doesn’t help the United States at all.

 

 

DEFENSIVE MIDFIELDER: Maurice EDU

 

Starting Maurice Edu with Michael Bradley ensures that Bradley will have defensive coverage from a skilled and athletic midfielder and defender that can also get forward with the attack with Bradley drops deeper. Using Edu as a defensive midfielder allows Geoff Cameron to start at center back where he is needed the most.

 

 

DEFENSIVE MIDFIELDER: Michael BRADLEY

 

Michael Bradley and Maurice Edu are both defensive midfielders that not only know how to participate in the attack but that also know to stay back deeper to provide defensive coverage so that the Back Four isn’t exposed. Bradley provides the needed defensive and constant running while also helping to control the team’s passing, in addition to setting up goals.

 

 

RIGHT ATTACKER: Joe CORONA

 

Using Joe Corona as the right attacker not only helps Benny Feilhaber to keep possession and create scoring chances but he also plays slightly deeper than Clint Dempsey who is really a forward in the form of a second striker. While Fabian Johnson could start here for his attacking skill and pace, Corona helps to link the defensive midfielders to Juan Agudelo and Clint Dempsey more so than Johnson does.

 

 

NUMBER 10: Benny FEILHABER

 

Benny Feilhaber is the best and most proven Number 10 or central attacking midfielder in the entire American player pool, and he has developed a strong two-way style of play full of running and defending. Feilhaber is a playmaker and skilled goal-scorer, but he has now also become a playmaker with the work rate and defender of a box-to-box midfielder.

 

 

LEFT ATTACKER: Clint DEMPSEY

 

As the best American player and attacker, Clint Dempsey lining up out left allows him to attack wide, cut inside, or sneak forward next to the striker. A free-flowing attacker like Dempsey has total freedom of movement for the United States, and starting him out left opens up a starting spot for Edu to start alongside Bradley in the defensive midfield to protect the back line and to help start the attack from the back. For most of his career, starting out left with the freedom to cut inside provided Dempsey with the most success because he could help provide link-up play with the striker and go forward to partner with the first striker.

 

 

STRIKER: Juan AGUDELO

 

Juan Agudelo is a more complete and more dangerous striker than Jozy Altidore. Agudelo’s touch, skill on the ball, creativity, and finishing are all superior to Altidore, and Agudelo has all of the athleticism and height of Altidore with good strength albeit not quite as much as the almost NFL strength of Altidore. Therefore, Agudelo brings Altidore’s athleticism and size with more skill, trickery, and better finishing. Agudelo is also much more active off the ball and more capable of attacking from wide positions and centrally. Finally, Agudelo is just as good or better than Altidore in the air. Altidore has been criticized at times for the inconsistency in the quality of his touch and skill on the ball, but no one has ever accused Agudelo of being technically lacking.

 

 

Tactical Formation (4-2-3-1):

 

GUZAN

YEDLIN CAMERON BROOKS KLUTE

BRADLEY EDU

CORONA FEILHABER DEMPSEY

AGUDELO

 

 

The Best American Footballers (August 2014)

 

 

Clint Dempsey has been the best American soccer player since 2006.
Clint Dempsey has been the best American soccer player since 2006.

 

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

These rankings aren’t based on skill alone, but they are a subjective ranking of American footballers factoring in skill, club form, international form, and athleticism. It’s impossible to weigh the various criteria evenly, and trying to compare attackers to midfielders to defenders to goalkeepers is even more difficult, as each position has different but equally important skill-sets.

 

Here are World Soccer Source’s rankings of the Best American Footballers as of August 2014:

 

1. Clint DEMPSEY

2. Landon DONOVAN

3. Michael BRADLEY

4. Fabian JOHNSON

5. Tim HOWARD

 

6. Jermaine JONES

7. Benny FEILHABER

8. Geoff CAMERON

9. Juan AGUDELO

10. Joe CORONA

 

11. DeAndre YEDLIN

12. Mix DISKERUD

13. Jozy ALTIDORE

14. Brad GUZAN

15. Maurice EDU

 

16. Eddie JOHNSON

17. John BROOKS

18. Benji JOYA

19. Dillon POWERS

20. Shane O’NEILL

 

21. Robbie ROGERS

22. Chris KLUTE

23. Michael OROZCO 

24. Michael PARKHURST

25. Matt BESLER

 

26. Julian GREEN

27. Andrew FARRELL

28. Lee NGUYEN

29. Kellyn ACOSTA

30. Gyasi ZARDES

 

 

A New USMNT Attack

 

Juan Agudelo. (Photo: Fred Kfoury/Icon SMI)
Juan Agudelo. (Photo: Fred Kfoury/Icon SMI)

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

 

Joe Corona and Clint Dempsey flanking Juan Agudelo on paper but really playing as attacking midfielders behind Agudelo is a big attacking upgrade for the United States Men’s National Team.

 

Those three players added to an American midfield comprised of Michael Bradley, Benny Feilhaber, and Benji Joya discussed in a previous article make for a formidable Front Six entirely made up of technically-skilled and athletic players with the ability to play high quality soccer.

 

On paper this is a 4-3-3 formation, but it’s really the same as the 4-2-3-1 formation.

 

Corona, Feilhaber, and Dempsey form the attacking midfield portion of the Front Six, and Bradley is the defensive midfielder lining up in front of the Back Four. Joya is a two-way central midfielder than defends and attacks in addition to helping to link Bradley to the likes of Corona, Feilhaber, and Dempsey.

 

In the same way, Corona, Feilhaber, and Dempsey help to make sure Agudelo sees plenty of the ball in the attacking third to maximize his effectiveness as a striker and goal-scorer.

 

This trident of Corona, Agudelo, and Dempsey is a departure from the formula Jürgen Klinsmann planned on using in the World Cup before Jozy Altidore was injured in the first game. Klinsmann appeared to be banking on Dempsey alone being the only real link between the midfield and the attack, but the trident as described above allows for a much more potent attack made up of more attackers that can combine with one another and create more scoring chances and hopefully finish them.

 

Corona, Agudelo, and Dempsey all passing and moving and swirling around in the attacking third makes for a much more fluid and dynamic combination of attackers who pass and move as opposed to just leaving Dempsey and Altidore isolated up top with no consistent service other than long balls.

 

The best choice of players is subjective but a midfield of Bradley, Feilhaber, and Joya behind an attack of Corona, Agudelo, and Dempsey is a big step in the right direction for the United States that is still considered a national team that lacks collective technical skill and inventive play by most of the world that admires the Americans’ determination, teamwork, and work rate but little else.

 

While many Americans love that their national team is known around the world for its mental toughness and running, this is another way of saying that Americans run a lot but lack the skill needed to consistently create scoring chances and beat top national teams from the run of play.

 

Using the Corona, Agudelo, and Dempsey trident is a way to immediately bolster the inventiveness, attacking skill, and dynamism of the American attack, and the United States would be wise to use these players who have all proven their worth either on the club level or internationally or both.

 

Another way to think of this trident is actually Corona, Feilhaber, and Dempsey forming the line of three attacking midfielders behind Agudelo, but Corona and Dempsey are both forward-midfield hybrids that look to score and get into the penalty box.

 

Below is the three-man USMNT attack that World Soccer Source backs for success.

 

Right Attacker: Joe CORONA 

*(Fabian JOHNSON)

 

Striker: Juan AGUDELO

 

Left Attacker: Clint DEMPSEY

 

 

A New USMNT Midfield

 

Benji Joya. (Photo: Chicago Fire)
Benji Joya. (Photo: Chicago Fire)

 

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

The goal to improve the quality of American soccer and of the United States Men’s National Team (USMNT) marches on, and the gap remains between the amount of quality possession and technical soccer that the USA plays and other national teams play.

 

While it’s vital to have a defense made up of quality defenders with good athleticism and skill on the ball and while it’s important to have attackers that can finish scoring chances and create scoring opportunities, the midfield is where the real battle is waged.

 

The need to have better link-up play between the defensive midfielders and the attack has been harped upon by observers of the USMNT, so there is no disagreement among observers that this element of the United States’ play needs to be improved.

 

If Michael Bradley and Jermaine Jones both start for the United States, then there is still not enough of a link-up midfielder and attacking midfielder in the Starting XI to solve the problem of poor passing and little creativity in the midfield.

 

Out of all of the players in the American player pool, perhaps none other than Benny Feilhaber is more equipped right now to provide the type of link-up play and creativity that is missing from the national team.

 

Given all of the praise that Feilhaber has received for his improved defense and two-way play along with his drastically improved fitness levels, it is only logical for Feilhaber to be the first name that needs to be added to the American midfield with Bradley, since the only real criticism of Feilhaber in the past was that he didn’t play enough defense.

 

Maybe it’s also time to start thinking of a box-to-box midfielder or central midfielder to take Jones’ place, even if Jones is still going strong and looking very fit as he approaches 33.

 

Who should Jones’ replacement be? Benji Joya or Dillon Powers.

 

The USMNT roster needs both Joya and Powers, but Joya is the more technical, quick, and creative of the two for the Starting XI. Powers might be a better combination of defending and attacking than Joya, but Joya’s work rate and defending are still excellent. To be clear, Powers is a skilled passer and technical player that knows how to set up goals and score goals, and his gifts and skills look high-caliber.

 

Although Bradley has been marketed as more of an attacking and creative player than he really is, the USA needs Bradley lining up in front of the defense where he can protect the Back Four and help to orchestrate the passing. Bradley is the best American defensive midfielder.

 

His tireless running and intense but clean tackling are huge assets to the American midfield, and they are invaluable to the center backs and outside backs for whom he is providing defensive coverage.

 

Bradley’s two-footed passing can help the United States to work the ball out of the back with possession, and as a defensive midfielder he can be a passing outlet for the defense.

 

One complaint about Jones has been his sometimes dirty tackling and knack for getting cards, and although this wasn’t a problem in the World Cup, Bradley doesn’t have this same problem with dirty tackling.

 

An American midfield comprised of Bradley, Feilhaber, and Joya gives the USA defensive coverage, technical players, and skilled passers in the midfield, and players like Joe Corona and Clint Dempsey lining up out right and left as attackers that drift inside and sort of form part of the midfield gives the United States enough skilled passers and gifted players in between the defense and the striker to produce the sort of improved possession and overall play that Jürgen Klinsmann and the United States are looking for.

 

To progress with the times and improve, the United States should think of its midfield as a three-player system composed of a defensive midfielder, a box-to-box midfielder, and a playmaker, and these players are listed below.

 

Defensive Midfielder: Michael BRADLEY

 

Playmaker: Benny FEILHABER

 

Central Midfielder: Benji JOYA

 

The reason that Corona and Dempsey are not listed to make the midfield a five-man system is because they are forward-midfield hybrids that help to provide more support for the striker and more link-up play for the midfielders.

 

Since Feilhaber has become a much fitter and much more two-way midfielder, his creativity, vision, and technical skill can be bolstered by having players like Corona and Dempsey to combine with, and let’s not forget Joya who is a complete midfielder with the attacking skill, speed, and quickness to be used as an attacker.

 

Bradley, Feilhaber, Joya, Corona, and Dempsey behind either Jozy Altidore or Juan Agudelo is a strong and balanced American midfield and attack that improves the overall technical ability of the national team, which is what all American soccer fans want to see now and in future games and touraments.

 

 

A New USMNT Defense

 

Chris Klute, the Best American Left Back. (Photo: Garrett Ellwood / Colorado Rapids)
Chris Klute, the Best American Left Back. (Photo: Garrett Ellwood / Colorado Rapids)

 

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

DeAndre Yedlin, Geoff Cameron, John Brooks, and Chris Klute. The new USMNT defense.

 

Before going any further, it’s important to point out immediately that Fabian Johnson has a really strong cases as a starter over Chris Klute.

 

Johnson has received rave reviews on the club and international level for his play as a left back and right back, and anyone that has seen him play knows his attacking quality, overall skill-level, two-footedness, and speed.

 

The Klute over Johnson opinion is based on the fact that Klute is more of a defender than Johnson and better at tracking back on defense sooner and not leaving open space behind him, and Klute is a lightning-fast player.

 

Johnson is a converted winger who is essentially world-class as a winger on either side who also does play the right and left back positions really well from an attacking standpoint, but Klute is a better defender who still excels at participating in the attack and playing crosses and passes from the flanks.

 

Johnson is a more technical attacker, but Klute is a better defender. Both players excel as left backs or as right backs.

 

Klute is a technical and two-footed player with underrated dribbling ability, but Johnson is a much more talented player in terms of his overall technical ability and attacking skills. Johnson can score goals, and Klute just doesn’t have the same ability to cut inside and score.

 

This is one of the the weapons that Klute needs to add to his game. His speed and ability to use both feet would be more dangerous if he looked to take shots and score more often than he does now.

 

But, if the USA wants a fast and modern two-way outside back, Klute provides much better defending while still bringing a constant attacking threat out wide. Klute’s speed is also something that is just an enormous weapon defensively and offensively.

 

Whatever gap there is between Klute’s technical ability and Johnson’s is made up for with the speed that Klute uses to track down attackers, to burst down the sideline in the attack, to cut off passes, to make tackles, and to dribble out of the back.

 

Perhaps the best use of Johnson is as a winger in a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 formation, but this would take a starting spot from Corona who knows how to orchestrate an attack and score and Dempsey who brings so much scoring ability and trickery to the attack.

 

Going forward, Yedlin and Cameron are the clear starting right back and right center back, and Brooks is a more complete and younger center back than Matt Besler who has done well for the United States and Sporting Kansas City.

 

The ability of Yedlin and Klute to get forward in the attack with pace and their ability to catch and defend speedy attackers make them the outside backs that the United States needs the most in the USMNT XI.

 

With Cameron and Brooks as the center back pairing and Yedlin and Klute as the outside back pairing, the United States has the type of defense that it’s looking for: a fast and technical one with strong defending.

 

Although this Back Four is a strong one and the type that the United States needs, the USMNT still needs to give Maurice Edu more minutes as a center back with Geoff Cameron, and Fabian Johnson and Chris Klute need to be tested against one another.

 

The Yedlin, Cameron, Brooks, and Klute Back Four looks to be a strong one, but each of those positions need second-choice options, plus Johnson’s best role needs to be discovered.

 

As World Soccer Source will back a three-man midfield of Michael Bradley, Benny Feilhaber, and Benji Joya in a latter article, in addition to an attack of Joe Corona, Juan Agudelo, and Clint Dempsey, Fabian Johnson’s attacking skill as a two-footed winger who excels on either side makes him a starting winger for most observers.

 

Maybe having Feilhaber and Corona in the Starting XI would cause those players to get in each other’s way, or maybe it’s necessary to have two playmakers like that for the USA to see better possession and create more scoring chances. Either way, Johnson is a lock on the roster, but really ironing out the best USA XI will take some experimentation and time.

 

For now, a Back Four of Yedlin, Cameron, Brooks, and Klute is a good starting point for the American defense, and Klute is more of an outside back than Johnson who really plays his best as a winger on either side.

 

 

Here is the USA Back Four that World Soccer Source supports:

 

Right Back: DeAndre YEDLIN

 

Center Back: Geoff CAMERON

 

Center Back: John BROOKS

 

Left Back: Chris KLUTE

 

 

The Best USMNT 23 (August 2014)

 

DeAndre Yedlin (Image via TopDrawerSoccer.com)
DeAndre Yedlin (Image via TopDrawerSoccer.com)

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

According to World Soccer Source, here is the Best USMNT 23 as of August 2014:

 

GOALKEEPER: Tim HOWARD, Brad GUZAN, Cody CROPPER

 

DEFENDERS: Geoff CAMERON, John BROOKS, Shane O’NEILL, Andrew FARRELL, DeAndre YEDLIN, Chris KLUTE, Kofi SARKODIE, Kellyn ACOSTA

 

MIDFIELDERS: Michael BRADLEY, Jermaine JONES, Benny FEILHABER, Maurice EDU, Fabian JOHNSON, Joe CORONA, Benji JOYA, Dillon POWERS

 

ATTACKERS: Clint DEMPSEY, Jozy ALTIDORE, Julian GREEN, Juan AGUDELO

 

 

Roster Notes:

 

– Center Back is a deep position on this roster. Cameron, Brooks, O’Neill, and Farrell are center backs, as is Edu. Brooks is naturally left-footed, so the United States has a clear left center back starter, not to mention Cameron and O’Neill who are perfectly comfortable and capable playing left center back or right center back. Cameron is the obvious right center back starter.

 

– Klute and Acosta play as right backs or left backs, and Yedlin and Sarkodie are really just right backs (although Yedlin can play left back). Farrell is also a right back.

 

– Bradley and Edu are listed as the defensive midfielders, but Cameron and O’Neill also excel in this role. Farrell is also known to do well as a midfield destroyer.

 

– Joya, Powers, Bradley, and Edu are all box-to-box midfielders in addition to other positions that they play whether those be defensive midfielders in Bradley’s and Edu’s case or playmakers in Joya’s and Powers’s case.

 

– Dempsey, Corona, F. Johnson, Green, and Joya can all play as wings on either side of the field.

 

– Dempsey and Green are midfield-forward hybrids that can play as second strikers or as wings.

 

– Altidore, and Agudelo are the Number 9s or first strikers on this roster, which gives the United States two out-and-out strikers in order to avoid the 2014 World Cup scenario where the roster only included one fully-healthy and quality striker, Altidore, who was injured in the first game. Aron Jóhannsson appears to have been playing injured even before the 2014 World Cup.

 

– Fabian Johnson listed as a midfielder because his best position is as a right or left winger, but Johnson is obviously a international-caliber right back or left back.

 

– Clear playmakers are present on this roster. Feilhaber and Corona are naturally central attacking midfielders, but Joya and Powers also excel in this role. Dempsey shines in this role as well where he’s really playing as a withdrawn striker, which is a variation of the central attacking midfielder.

 

– Each position of the 4-2-3-1 is at least two players deep on this roster, and the flexibility of so many of the players gives the United States plenty of tactical options and formation choices, including the fluid 4-3-3 formation.

 

 

Is It Time for the USMNT to Use a 4-3-3?

 

Joe Benny Corona (Photo: Club Tijuana)
Joe Benny Corona (Photo: Club Tijuana)

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

With two international friendlies on the horizon, the United States Men’s National Team has to look to improve its mediocre passing in the 2014 World Cup, and it’s time to take stock of the player pool.

 

The 4-3-3 formation quickly becomes the 4-2-3-1 formation, but thinking of the USMNT as a 4-3-3 formation is a convenient way to list a balanced midfield and attack in a sport where players’ positions are so fluid.

 

As some attacking midfielders that play wide or centrally are referred to as forwards or attackers nowadays while other similar players are listed as midfielders, fielding a midfield three comprised of a defensive midfielder, a box-to-box midfielder, and a playmaker or central attacking midfielder is a simple and logical way begin forming a USA XI.

 

Most of this is semantics, and the important things are to have defensive coverage in front of the defense and to have link-up play between the defensive midfielders and the attacking players.

 

Nevertheless, selecting a defensive midfielder, a two-way central midfielder, and a playmaker is a great method to ensure that the USA has a nice balance of players in the midfield.

 

AS Roma is associate with the 4-3-3, and that’s exactly the type of soccer that the United States is looking to play – proactive with an organized and traditional defense made up of two-way outside backs and two center backs.

 

Tab Ramos in an interview with Soccer America explained how his U-20 USMNT roster from the last U-20 World Cup had Will Trapp as the defensive midfielder, Benji Joya as the box-to-box midfielder, and Luis Gil as the Number 10.

 

It’s easy to see how this playing philosophy demonstrates a strong fundamental understanding of how to field a midfield that is a balance between defending and attacking.

 

In addition to the three types of midfielders listed above, let some of the wingers or wide attacking midfielders that like to cut inside be listed as forwards if that makes selecting a balanced roster easier.

 

The important thing is to be two players deep at all 11 positions in a common and proven tactical formation such as the 4-2-3-1, the 4-3-3, or the 4-1-4-1. The players on the field are just going to move around constantly anyway.

 

Putting two defensive midfielders, two box-to-box midfielders, and two playmakers on the 23-man roster eliminates the problem that the United States had in the 2014 World Cup: no link-up play between the defensive midfielders and the attack.

 

For the United States right now, the midfield has to begin with Michael Bradley as the defensive midfielder, and Benny Feilhaber continues to make his case as the best American playmaker in the pool, plus he has the international experience and success to back up this claim.

 

Selecting a box-to-box midfielder is more difficult and controversial for many people. Should the USA go with a new talent like Benji Joya or Dillon Powers, or is it too soon?

 

Landon Donovan, DeAndre Yedlin, and Juan Agudelo have all debunked the belief that young and inexperienced American players can’t deliver on the international level, and Joya is at the top of the list as far as young American box-to-box midfielders go.

 

By all accounts, Joya is the central midfielder that will be a fixture for the USMNT for the next 10 plus years.

 

Dillon Powers is another option, and perhaps he should already be thought of as the second-choice box-to-box midfielder behind Joya.

 

Either way, Joya and Powers are ready to be on the roster now because the best you can do is pick your best players for each position even if they aren’t too experienced internationally.

 

Talented young players need to be allowed to play to keep a club or national team with a steady pipeline of talent with playing time.

 

The other advantage of both Joya and Powers on the roster is that the USA does have the option of using a midfield three comprised of two box-to-box midfielders with a defensive midfielder.

 

With two box-to-box midfielders flanking a defensive midfielder, the playmaker on paper can just be in the front line of three attackers who will all be constantly moving, roaming around, and swapping positions with one another, except for the striker who should be playing higher and looking to stretch the defense.

 

For simplicity’s sake, a three-man midfield made up of Joya, Bradley, and Feilhaber is a technical and athletic group that are all two way players with some differing skill-sets.

 

The four-man defense should be a foregone conclusion. Whether one chooses Fabian Johnson or Chris Klute as the left back, the USA Back Four should be DeAndre Yedlin, Geoff Cameron, John Brooks, and Johnson or Klute.

 

The argument can be made for Matt Besler as the left center back, but Brooks is a better 1v1 defender, more two-footed, and a Bundesliga starter. Brooks is therefore a better defender and a better soccer player than Besler, plus he’s younger. This makes Brooks the better option.

 

The three-man attack is really two attacking midfielders plus a striker. With Joe Corona out right and Clint Dempsey out left, both players can cut inside, play wide, and float behind Juan Agudelo who is the most talented and complete striker in the American pool.

 

Both Corona and Dempsey are attacking midfielders that are always looking to score and to get into the penalty box, so using these two players behind Agudelo gives the American attack lots of combination play and goal-scoring ability.

 

In many ways this set-up is just a 4-2-3-1 in disguise (with Corona, Feilhaber, and Dempsey as the line of three), but listing it as a 4-3-3 is a convenient way to separate the midfielders with the midfield-forward hybrids like Corona and Dempsey.

 

Bradley and Joya would be the line of two defensive midfielders – with Joya being the box-to-box midfielder and Bradley being the stay-at-home defensive midfielder. Corona, Feilhaber, and Dempsey would be the line of three attacking midfielders, and Agudelo would be the striker.

 

This sort of balanced and organized tactical set-up would allow the United States to maximize its talent while not continuing to play too defensively without the link-up players needed to have an effective and technical attack.

 

What would a USMNT 4-3-3 look like?

 

GUZAN

YEDLIN CAMERON BROOKS KLUTE/JOHNSON

JOYA BRADLEY FEILHABER

CORONA AGUDELO DEMPSEY 

 

– This USA XI includes four lines of players comprised of a goalkeeper, a defense, a midfield, and an attack.

 

– Specifically, this 4-3-3- has a goalkeeper, a right back, two center backs, a left back, a  box-to-box midfielder, a defensive midfielder, a playmaker, two attacking midfielders that line up out wide and cut inside, and a striker.

 

– With this USA XI, it’s also easy to select a suitable back-up for each of the 10 field positions, plus two more goalkeepers.

 

Who Should Start in the MLS All-Star Game?

 

Clint Dempsey. (Photo: Getty Images)
Clint Dempsey. (Photo: Getty Images)

 

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

 

The MLS-All Star roster has no left back. This was inexcusable for MLS All-Star coach Caleb Porter because The MLS All-Star Game is a marketing tool to try to beat a famous European club in order to up the profile of the league.

 

The absence of Chris Klute from the roster to start at left back was a big oversight by MLS, especially with an excellent two-way right back like Yedlin on the roster. Having two skilled and speedy outside backs would have been a better advertisement for the league.

 

The fans voted for 11 starters, omitting a left back, but Porter doesn’t have to start these 11 players. Porter’s job was then to select 10 more players, not including MLS commissioner Don Garber’s two picks.

 

This brought the roster to 23 players.

 

Unfortunately the roster doesn’t include a left back, so it would seem that both Porter and Garber are to blame for not selecting a left back or at least another outside back that can play on the left.

 

Given the lack of a left back on the roster, picking a Best XI to face Bayern Munich requires immediately figuring out who to stick at left back, so that Bayern doesn’t run amok on the MLS All-Stars, which they might very well do anyway.

 

Sticking Michael Parkhurst at left back is the best option to face Bayern Munich because at least Parkhurst has experience playing the position on the international level.

 

Some of the other Starting XI choices should be easy for Porter, if he picks the best players and the best combination of players. DeAndre Yedlin should be a lock as the starting right back, and Osvaldo Alonso and Michael Bradley should be locks as the defensive midfielders.

 

In the attack, starting Tim Cahill as the central attacking midfielder behind teammate Thierry Henry is the strongest option, and flanking Cahill with Seattle teammates Obafemi Martins and Clint Dempsey gives the MLS All-Stars the most skill and firepower against a team of Bayern Munich’s caliber.

 

The two center back spots are highly debatable. Aurelien Collin and Matt Besler is an obvious option because of their chemistry playing for Sporting Kansas City.

 

Maurice Edu was a late edition to the All-Star Game, and Edu is an interesting option to start at center back with Besler because of his international experience and center back play with the Philadelphia Union.

 

Perhaps an Edu-Besler partnership is the best advertisement for the league, and it could also help out the United States Men’s National Team by giving Edu minutes with Besler, which is a strong partnership that the United States could use in the future.

 

Edu and Besler both certainly possess the right type of combination of defending, speed, and skill on the ball needed to be competitive against a team like Bayern.

 

If the objective is to beat Bayern Munich, then starting Henry as the lone striker with Martins, Cahill, and Dempsey floating behind him offers elite talent and tons of experience against world-class competition.

 

With Osvaldo and Bradley protecting the defense and manning the back of the midfield, the attackers listed above have plenty of defensive coverage behind them, and those attackers should be providing a significant amount of pressure on the Bayern Munich defense as well.

 

The best Starting XI is debatable and up to Porter, but the line-up below is arguably the strongest and most balanced XI amongst the roster options.

 

 

The Best MLS ALL-STAR XI (4-2-3-1)

 

GK: Nick RIMANDO (Real Salt Lake)

 

RB: DeAndre YEDLIN (Seattle Sounders)

CB: Maurice EDU (Philadelphia Union)

CB: Matt BESLER (Sporting KC)

LB: Michael PARKHURST (Columbus Crew)

 

DM: Osvaldo ALONSO (Seattle Sounders)

CM: Michael BRADLEY (Toronto FC)

 

RW: Obafemi MARTINS (Seattle Sounders)

CAM: Tim CAHILL (New York Red Bulls)

LW: Clint DEMPSEY (Seattle Sounders)

 

S: Thierry HENRY (New York Red Bulls)

 

 

Who does World Soccer Source think should start in the MLS All-Star Game not restricting the options to the 23-man roster picked or the Starting XI voted upon?

 

The World Soccer Source MLS All-Star XI (4-3-3):

 

GK: Clint IRWIN (Colorado Rapids)

 

RB: DeAndre YEDLIN (Seattle Sounders)

CB: Shane O’NEILL (Colorado Rapids)

CB: Matt BESLER (Sporting KC)

LB: Chris KLUTE (Colorado Rapids)

 

CM: Michael BRADLEY (Toronto FC)

DM: Osvaldo ALONSO (Seattle Sounders)

CM: Benny FEILHABER (Sporting KC)

 

F: Tim CAHILL (New York Red Bulls)

F: Thierry HENRY (New York Red Bulls)

F: Clint DEMPSEY (Seattle Sounders)

 

 

Tactical Formation:

 

IRWIN

YEDLIN O’NEILL BESLER KLUTE

BRADLEY ALONSO FEILHABER

CAHILL HENRY DEMPSEY

 

 

Editor’s Note: Omar Gonzalez was originally listed as the starting center back with Matt Besler in the original version of this article, but Gonzalez was dropped from the roster on August 2nd due to the fact that he’d be playing a club game two days later. Maurice Edu was added to the roster on August 2nd as well.

USMNT: Replaceable World Cup Players

 

Chris Klute (arms raised). (Photo: USA Today SPORTS)
Chris Klute (arms raised). (Photo: USA Today SPORTS)

 

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

Many American soccer writers, commentators, pundits, and fans won’t ever even consider the use of young and inexperienced American players on the United States Men’s National Team because those players aren’t the current starters, so there’s never any real pressure placed on the USMNT to conduct an actual examination of the player pool, which holds the United States back.

 

Better national teams are comprised of players playing in top European or Latin American leagues, so although the World Cup or international play is a different animal, new players’ club play offers up a sense of how they will perform at the international level against top competition.

 

Cruising along with the status quo is a bad strategy for the USMNT to close the gap with first and second-tier national teams.

 

The United States needs to start bringing new and talented players into the fold and see how they do. If these players don’t appear to be capable of playing well at the international level after several appearances, then other players should be tried out.

 

U.S. Soccer keeps a list of players in the pool, but there definitely needs to be a list of around 100 players organized by position that need to be monitored.

 

Here, World Soccer Source identifies 12 players from the United States Men’s National Team’s World Cup squad that Jürgen Klinsmann should continue to use, and 11 new players that are needed to fill the remaining roster spots and improve the national team are also identified.

 

 

PLAYERS THE USMNT SHOULD KEEP:

 

GK: Tim HOWARD, Brad GUZAN

CB: Geoff CAMERON, John BROOKS

OB: DeAndre YEDLIN, Fabian JOHNSON

DM: Jermaine JONES, Michael BRADLEY

AM: Clint DEMPSEY, Mix DISKERUD, Julian GREEN

S: Jozy ALTIDORE

 

 

PLAYERS THE USMNT SHOULD DROP/ADD:

 

OUT: Nick RIMANDO

IN: Cody CROPPER

 

OUT: Omar GONZALEZ

IN: Shane O’NEILL

 

OUT: Matt BESLER

IN: Michael OROZCO

 

OUT: DaMarcus BEASLEY

IN: Chris KLUTE

 

OUT: Timothy CHANDLER

IN: Kellyn ACOSTA

 

OUT: Kyle BECKERMAN

IN: Maurice EDU

 

OUT: Alejandro BEDOYA

IN: Joe CORONA

 

OUT: Brad DAVIS

IN: Benji JOYA

 

OUT: Graham ZUSI

IN: Dillon POWERS

 

OUT: Chris WONDOLOWSKI

IN: Juan AGUDELO

 

OUT: Aron JÓHANNSSON

IN: Benny FEILHABER*

 

*Not a like-for-like switch but the final roster has a first and second choice option for each spot in the 4-2-3-1 formation.

 

 

The Updated USMNT Roster:

 

GK: Tim HOWARD, Brad GUZAN, Cody CROPPER

 

RB: DeAndre YEDLIN, Kellyn ACOSTA

RCB: Geoff CAMERON, Shane O’NEILL

LCB: John BROOKS, Michael OROZCO

LB: Chris KLUTE, Fabian JOHNSON

 

DM: Michael BRADLEY, Maurice EDU

CM: Jermaine JONES, Dillon POWERS

 

RW: Joe CORONA, Benji JOYA

CAM: Benny FEILHABER, Mix DISKERUD

LW: Clint DEMPSEY, Julian GREEN

 

S: Jozy ALTIDORE, Juan AGUDELO

 

 

 

Abbreviation Guide:

 

GK- Goalkeeper

CB- Center Back

OB- Outside Back

RB- Right Back

RCB- Right Center Back

LCB- Left Center Back

LB- Left Back

DM- Defensive Midfielder

CM- Central Midfielder

AM– Attacking Midfielder

RW- Right Wing

CAM- Central Attacking Midfielder

LW- Left Wing

S- Striker

 

 

Does Brazilian Football Require an Overhaul?

 

Neymar, Brazil's brightest star. (Photo: Getty Images)
Neymar, Brazil’s brightest star. (Photo: Getty Images)

 

By: COLIN REESE

 

Does Brazilian football really need an overhaul?

 

Yes and no.

 

Brazil continues to have an abundance of world-class players at every position, but many former and current players, journalists, pundits, and the like have all gone on record lamenting the problems with the running of the Confederação Brasileira de Futebol (CBF) and the problem with young Brazilian players in Europe being made less creative and dynamic by their European coaches.

 

Domestically, the CBF needs to listen to the advice of all of the great Brazilian soccer minds, coaches, players, and ex-players that have specific ideas of what they want changed and how to do it, and these ideas need to be put into action.

 

Abroad, European teams want to get Brazilians while they are young, but they often want to take the Brazilian characteristics out of the players. Europeans want Brazilians because of their skill on the ball, but they want Brazilians to adapt to the European way of playing.

 

The problem with this approach is that many of the very best and most successful European players like Zinedine Zidane played like Brazilians – or even better. The elements that have made Brazilian players the most highly sought after are what European teams are paying for, so they need to be careful to not ruin their Brazilian players.

 

Since Brazilian players develop fantastic technical skill on their own outside of any organization as young children, there’s no real problem with Brazil’s development of players, minus the absence of a better striker on the 2014 World Cup team.

 

The reason for this particular absence was because the striker phenom, Pato, was supposed to be the striker on the 2010 and the 2014 Brazil World Cup squads. In theory, Brazil had been grooming Pato to be the Number 9 since he was a teenager. Injuries and some inconsistent club form because of the injuries have derailed this plan until now, but Pato is only 24 going on 25 years old.

 

If Brazil’s World Cup squad had used a stronger and more creative attack consisting of Lucas, Oscar, Neymar, and Pato, the attack might have been much effective and exciting, which likely would have pressured Germany too much in the back to allow Germany to score seven goals in a World Cup semifinal.

 

There might have never been the 7-1 loss to Germany in the 2014 World Cup semifinal, and the subsequent crisis might have never been.

 

Hulk and Fred in particular were like dead weight for the Seleção in the World Cup, and the failure to include better options on the roster or to drop Hulk and Fred when they were underperforming were major problems.

 

From a purely soccer standpoint, there is no shortage of technical, creative, and athletic Brazilian players at every position, and the non-structured manner in which many Brazilians learn to play is in fact the reason that they are so good.

 

Therefore, any changes to Brazil’s academies and youth development need to be done in such a way as to not eliminate the unique way in which Brazilian kids learn how to play soccer with such skill and creativity with the ball.

 

There are problems with the management of the CBF, but these problems don’t affect the early development of world-class Brazilian players that learn to play by playing pick-up soccer, juggling, and just practicing with the ball.

 

It’s important to remember that Brazil did just reach the semifinals with an impressive group of world-class players, so many of the arguments about Brazilian football being in a state of complete crisis are just mass hysteria and exaggeration.

 

The two big takeaways from Brazil’s performance in the 2014 World Cup are: 1.) the Seleção needed to give Neymar and Oscar better attacking partners; and 2.) Brazil needed to recollect themselves after conceding an early first goal to Thomas Müller of Germany in the semifinal game.

 

Brazilian football isn’t going to drop out of elite status because of one embarrassing goleada, and Brazil did use a tactically sound 4-2-3-1 formation where there was a defensive midfielder, a box-to-box midfielder, a playmaker, two wide attacking midfielders that looked to cut inside, and a striker. Plus, the Brazilian defense featured four defenders that almost anyone would consider world-class.

 

In the wake of the 2014 World Cup, Neymar and many others have said that Brazil needs to catch up with Germany in how they train and prepare, but the thing that Brazil has that no one else has is still there: a bottomless pit of world-class players with a unique and creative way of mastering control over a soccer ball.

 

The Seleção needs to continue to use creative and technical players at every position, and it needs to combine the somewhat recently improved caliber of its center backs and defensive midfielders with the types of outside backs, creative midfielders, and attackers that can score, keep possession, and display creativity like no other national team.

 

Going forward, Dunga needs to make sure that he uses players that look to quickly pass and combine with one another, so that Brazil can exploit its greatest asset: creative and highly technical players.

 

One thing to keep repeating is that Brazil did in fact reach the semifinals, which it lost terribly without two of its best players: Neymar and Thiago Silva, the most important attacker and the most important defender.

 

Brazil is a soccer crazed country of over 200 million people that consistently produces the best players, so maybe, just maybe, all this talk of jogo bonito being dead is just the overreaction of a country with unrealistically high expectations of its players and huge overreactions to its losses – even really embarrassing losses.

 

Hulk and Fred didn’t work out, so it’s time to give their spots to different players that can help Neymar and Oscar to put the opposition on its heels.

 

Dunga needs to take stock of the talent pool and use the best players at each position in the 4-2-3-1 formation, or perhaps the Brazilian 4-2-2-2 formation.

 

Brazilian football is still alive and well, and Neymar is its king.